Ad-/Tracking-Modules and Privacy Checker
That's not only annoying in many cases, but also a general security risk – as ad- and tracking-modules inherit all permissions from their „host-apps“. Moreover, there are other hidden costs of advertisements: with websites, they at best make up 50% of your traffic, in some cases more than 90%! Not to forget that sometimes there are also malicious ads – something Google Ads isn´t safe from either. So what can be done?
- Buy apps. Usually, the paid versions do not contain ad-modules (exception: if the paid version is to be used as an addon to the free one; but unfortunately there are also other exceptions).
- If there's no paid version (or that contains „sniffers“ as well): think about using an AdBlocker (in most cases, this requires root)
- Alternatively, think about using a Firewall or Permission Blocker.
- Take your apps exclusively from F-Droid (in my lists they can be identified by the F-Droid Icon). According to a study from 9/2017 this is the only place where neither Adware nor Malware was found (at Google Play they found e.g. ca. 2% Malware)
And if you think it’s only the online shops which are bugged: Nope. In offline stores, secret surveillance tracks your every move as well.
To protect yourself against that, you’ve first got to identify affected apps and places.
I need privacy. Not because my actions are questionable, but because 'your' judgement and intentions are.
And it doesn't matter whether or not my communications are weighty or frivolous in nature - they are mine and only for those whom I've chosen to share them with. Not the government's, nor goog's, nor my ISP's, but mine.
Also, what is legal where I live today, may not be legal tomorrow and my discussion of it may incriminate my future self. It has happened in the past many times to others in other places.
Identify Ad-Modules
- Exodus (4.2@1,111) 5 Github; Video Walk-Through 6/2018; Vorstellung 9/2018 | 5/2019 | 7/2021; IzzyOnDroid 6/2019
- AirPush Detector (3.8@42,618) 0 LastUpdate: 2013-07-22
- TrustGo Ad Detector (3.7@11,451) 2 LastUpdate: 2015-01-02
- Addons Detector (3.6@8,362) Ǥ 8 1 Review 2/2018
- AppBrain Ad Detector (3.5@11,134) 7 Intro 9/2018; also lists Social SDKs and developer toolkits; scan engine (database) is still updated even if the app was not
- Goclean: Popup Ad detector (3.1@5,526) Ǥ 25 13
- Ad Detector (2.1@2,940) 2 1 LastUpdate: 2013-07-11
- ClassyShark3xodus - Scan apps for warnings (0@0) 5
- TrackerControl (0@0) 12 1 / TC Slim – Study app tracking (4.2@365) 11 1 / TrackerControl (0@0) 12 1 Github; Intro 11/2019 | 8/2020; find and (except slim) block / Github
Privacy-Checker
For general privacy-risks, a.o. the following apps watching out:
- tSpyChecker (5@1,761) 0 LastUpdate: 2017-03-27
- Privacy Guard (4.3@206) Ǥ 6 1 LastUpdate: 2019-09-14
- Spyware Detector Anti Spy Scan (4.2@136,281) Ǥ 18 9
- Cameraless - Camera Blocker (4.2@9,135) Ǥ 14 3 LastUpdate: 2020-10-29 blocks camera access
- Microphone Block: Mic Anti Spy (4.2@8,338) Ǥ 14 3 / Microphone Block Pro: Anti spy (3.9@834; ~EUR 20.00) Ǥ 7
- Privacy Scanner (AntiSpy) (4.2@2,139) 2 / Privacy Scanner (AntiSpy) Pro (3.9@112) Ǥ 3
- Anti Spy (SpyWare Removal) (4.2@1,891) 3 2 LastUpdate: 2020-05-17
- Exodus (4.2@1,111) 5 Github; Video Walk-Through 6/2018; Vorstellung 9/2018 | 5/2019 | 7/2021; IzzyOnDroid 6/2019
- Anti Spy Mobile PRO (4.1@1,655; ~EUR 5.00) Ǥ 3 LastUpdate: 2021-11-14 AppThread@XDA-Forum
- Message Spy Remover (Anti Spy) (4.1@1,135) 7 2 LastUpdate: 2020-03-16
- Malloc Privacy & Security (4@9,949) Ǥ 22 5 camera /microphone access in the free version; premium adds VPN, connection reports, scan for spyware + other critical apps, anti-theft
- Androlyzer - Privacy Scanner (4@84) 4 LastUpdate: 2016-11-05 Detection of malware, spyware, trojans and undesired data leaks; see website
- Lumen Privacy Monitor (3.9@216) 14 3 LastUpdate: 2020-05-20
- MyPermissions Privacy Cleaner (3.7@6,144) Ǥ 9 7 LastUpdate: 2019-04-07 alarms you as soon as an app accesses your private data (but not before)
- Anti Spy for Paranoids (3.7@172) 3 2 LastUpdate: 2020-03-08
- SpyCamBlocker (deprecated) (3.5@194) 2 LastUpdate: 2014-03-14 Disables camera access
- Camera Block Pro: Anti spyware (3.2@1,977; ~EUR 20.00) Ǥ 7
- Hidden Apps (2.8@4,101) 2 3 LastUpdate: 2021-01-04
- Ruam Mij (0@0) 2 Github
- Warden (0@0) 8 LastUpdate: 2020-07-04 GitLab; Vorstellung 7/2020; tracker checker and nuker; needs root (to nuke)
- Vigilante (0@0) 8 LastUpdate: 2023-02-12 Github; alerts you when an app accesses camera or microphone
Other Sniffer-Detectors
- Fake Hotspot Detector -AntiSpy (4.7@326) 11 2 LastUpdate: 2020-04-26
- Bluetooth Radar (4.6@110) 16 Github; control and monitor Bluetooth and wearable devices around you
- Beacon Scope (4.4@64) 12 1
- Wi-Fi Privacy Police (4.3@1,203) 5 LastUpdate: 2016-10-08 Github; protects against WiFi tracking
- SpyWare Removal (Anti Spy) (4.3@696) 3 2 LastUpdate: 2020-04-01
- WireTap Detection (Anti Spy) (4.1@6,975) 9 2 LastUpdate: 2020-03-06
- HttpCanary — Capture & Injection Master (4.1@5,102) 8 LastUpdate: 2020-10-28 User Manual
- Privacy Indicators (4.1@298) 2 LastUpdate: 2021-07-15 Github; notifies you when an app accesses camera or microphone
- Cell Spy Catcher (Anti Spy) (4@3,446) 8 2 LastUpdate: 2020-03-19 detect Stingray Cell Phone Trackers („IMSI catchers“)
- WireTap and Spy Removal (4@3,208) 11 2 LastUpdate: 2020-03-10 Needs your location to detect wiretaps?
- Skewy - anti eavesdropping (4@223) 3 Github; prevent eavesdropping and ultrasonic access of your smart phone
- SafeDot (3.9@85) 6 LastUpdate: 2022-07-17 Github; notifies you when an app accesses camera or microphone
- Beacon Scanner (3.8@529) Ǥ 8 3 LastUpdate: 2020-01-20 check whether a place is bugged with Bluetooth beacons
- SnoopSnitch (3.5@4,016) 16 Intro 7/2019; Vorstellung 4/2018 | 1/2020; Mike’s favorite; detect Stingray Cell Phone Trackers and missing security patches
- [root] Pry-Fi (3.3@6,895) Ǥ 10 LastUpdate: 2014-02-17 Vorstellung 2/2014; Intro 2/2014; Test 3/2014; protects against being WiFi-sniffed
- Tracker Detect (1.9@4,855) 8 LastUpdate: 2022-02-28 Intro 12/2021 | 12/2021; Vorstellung 12/2021; protect yourself from Apple's Find My Tracking
- AirGuard - AirTag protection (0@0) 17 Github; Vorstellung 9/2021; protect yourself from Apple's Find My Tracking
- HideDroid (0@0) 8 Github; Vorstellung 10/2021; anonymizes network traffic from analytics modules
Other means of privacy protection
- MockTraffic (0@0) 4 Github; random DNS, HTTPS internet traffic noise generator
Further Readings:
- Category Ad-Blocker
- Category Anti-Virus, Anti-Malware, Anti-Theft
- Category App-Locker
- Category Permissions
- Beware those snooping mods! in the help section
- MobilSicher AppCheck
- Für Anfänger/Bequeme: Werbung und Tracker unter iOS/Android systemweit verbannen
- PrivacyGrade: Grading The Privacy Of Smartphone Apps
- Das inoffizielle Android Handbuch: Risiken werbefinanzierter Apps / Privacy / Verbindungsdaten
- Privacy settings with Google: Google Settings Is a Super Useful Android App You've Probably Ignored
- Why „I´ve got nothing to hide“ is wrong: 7 videos a 15 min by DoNotTrack
- Lots of Videos & Podcasts on privacy topics at Privacy International
- Checkliste: Apps richtig beurteilen
- Mit der App "PCAPdroid" Datenverbindungen aktiver SDKs erkennen
- 4 Methods to Identify and Block App Tracking on Android (11/2023)
- How Ads on Your Phone Can Aid Government Surveillance (10/2023)
- Standort richtig verbergen – so gehen Geheimdienste vor (3/2023)
- Android launches yet another way to spy on users with “Privacy Sandbox” beta (2/2023)
- Avoid These 3 Types of App if You Care About Privacy (7/2022)
- How to Stop Your Android Phone From Tracking You (6/2022)
- Alle haben etwas zu verbergen: if you value your privacy, you should avoid using many apps (6/2022)
- Achtung, Handy hört mit: Smartphone-Apps als Wanze (3/2022)
- How to block and monitor ad trackers on Android (1/2022)
- Lobby-Analyse: Google, Facebook & Co. untergraben Verbot "spionierender" Werbung (1/2022)
- Tracking durch Identitätsprovider (12/2021)
- Bundeskartellamt: Sektoruntersuchung Mobile Apps (8/2021)
- How it should be done: New insights into clean analytics (3/2021)
- My Phone Was Spying on Me, so I Tracked Down the Surveillants (12/2020)
how data collected by ad modules travels to (un)expected places - App Tracking: Es ist noch viel, viel schlimmer (10/2020)
- Android Security: How to Stay Private With Your Phone (6/2020)
- Video: Was tut eine App wirklich? How MobilSicher analyses data traffic (2/2020)
- Video (~3min): What Is Privacy?
- New study: The advertising industry is systematically breaking the law (1/2020)
- Datenhandel mit Dating-Apps: Wir Konsumroboter taz.de (1/2020)
- How ultrasonic tracking apps may be listening to you and how to block them (10/2019 - 1/2023)
- Video from CCCamp2019 (~6min): Lightning Talk: Android! Privacy is not a Luxury (8/2019)
- IMSI-Catcher: So lassen sich Informationen übers Handynetz abfangen (8/2019)
- Wie Apps Sicherheitsmechanismen umgehen: 1 | 2 (8/2019)
- Why just checking permissions is insufficient (and you should rather prefer FOSS apps): More than 1,000 Android apps harvest data even after you deny permissions (7/2019)
- In Stores, Secret Surveillance Tracks Your Every Move (Bluetooth Beacons; 6/2019)
- Alphonso: Smartphone-Apps hören uns legal für Werbung ab (6/2019)
- How do tracking companies know what you did last summer? (5/2019)
- Was dürfen Eure Android-Apps? Die erschreckende Antwort… (3/2019 - 7/2020)
- App-Werbung: Betrug mit verdeckten Videos (3/2019)
- Thousands of apps are illegally working around the ad ID (2/2019)
- Geschwätzige Android-Apps send detailed data to Facebook (12/2018)
- Werbe-Apps: Von nervig bis gefährlich (12/2018 - 1/2020)
- I asked an online tracking company for all of my data and here's what I found (11/2018)
- Wenn das Smartphone wissen will, was im Fernsehen läuft (11/2018)
- Study: Third Party Tracking in the Mobile Ecosystem (PDF; 10/2018)
90% of the investigated 1M Playstore-Apps set up to transfer information back to Google - Now Apps Can Track You Even After You Uninstall Them / Apps kommunizieren mit Nutzern – auch wenn sie deinstalliert sind (10/2018)
- Mobile app data sharing 'out of control' (10/2018)
- Apps: Datenschutzerklärung vs. tatsächlich gesammelte Daten (9/2018)
- Stalkerware: Schutz vor Überwachung ist möglich (7/2018 - 4/2022)
- Zu Hülf: Meine App spioniert mich aus! (6/2018)
- Werbe-ID ändern: So verwischen Sie Ihre Spuren (5/2018 - 1/2022)
- App-Module (SDKs): So tracken Apps ihre Nutzer (5/2017 - 5/2023)
- App-Module als Sicherheitsrisiko (4/2018)
- Study finds over 3,300 Android apps improperly tracking kids (4/2018)
- Android: Facebook-Wanze in vielen Apps (4/2018)
- Datenlobby kämpft mit Tracking-Brandbrief gegen ePrivacy (3/2018 - 2/2022)
- Android: Elegante Lösung gegen WLAN-Tracking (3/2018)
- To Avoid Malware, Try the F-Droid App Store (1/2018)
- LightsOut und Co.: Android-Adware im Google Play Store (1/2018)
- Anyone can buy online ads and track your location in real time (10/2017)
- Schnüffel-Module in Apps: Das können Sie tun (5/2017 - 10/2020)
- Tracking im Internet: Cookies, Cache & Co (3/2017 - 1/2021)
- So bekommen Sie mehr Privatsphäre bei Android (3/2017)
- Datenhändler: Wir sind gläsern – Datensammler (Artikelserie, Start 1/2017)
- Video: The Terrifying Cost of »Free« Websites (12/2016) Watch this!
- Wie im Internet Geld verdient wird – Markt und Macht der Werbebranche (10/2016 - 2/2020)
- Warum Datenschutz jeden angeht (und nicht nur diejenigen, die etwas angestellt haben) (7/2016)
- Ortsdaten von zwei Apps reichen, um Nutzer zu identifizieren (4/2016)
- Tausende Apps scheffeln mit unsichtbarer Werbung Geld (7/2015)
- Privatsphäre auf dem Smartphone: So schützt Ihr Eure Daten (4/2015 - 1/2020)
- Free Apps May Be Tracking Your Phone Without Your Consent (3/2015)
- Invisible Infrastructures : Online Trackers (3/2015)
- Hallo, Datenkrake! – So formt die Werbeindustrie detaillierte Nutzerprofile 1 | 2 | 3 (7/2014)
- 2013: Zielgruppenspezifische Malware und der Aufstieg (und Niedergang) von Adware (2/2014)
- Die Privatsphäre als Produkt: Datenschutz als Geschäftsmodell (2/2014)
- Studie: Kostenlose Apps verbrauchen bis zu 75 % der Energie für Werbung (3/2012)